Sunday, June 30, 2013

Every Kid Needs a Champion


Every educator should watch this seven minute Ted Talk by Rita Pierson. Incredible.  It does not have a lot to do with reading, but it is well worth your time (I never like when people tell me that, but it is short, at least)




Now back to Proust and the Squid by Maryanne Wolf.  I read her words on fluency with interest as my seven year old son is apparently lacking in fluency.  He reads thirteen words fluently and should be reading in the fifty range.  Not being a reading teacher or an elementary teacher, I am not quite sure what this means, but I have determined that the reason why his fluency is so low is because he cannot sit still long enough to focus.  He simply cannot focus long enough to really read and understand before he moves on to the next thing.  Wolf writes that "fluency is not a matter of speed; it is a matter of being able to utilize all the special knowledge a child has about a word-its letters, letter patterns, meanings,grammatical functions, roots and endings-fast enough to have time to think and comprehend" (131).  In her definition of fluency, a child cannot  be considered a reader until they know the meanings of the words.  

So, if we define words and teach them what they mean, they will be better able to decode quickly and thereby have age appropriate fluency.    She attributes fluency to inferences and insights.  In this case, should we be doing DIBELS testing which is a test of fluency by reading unrelated words read quickly and they even read nonsense words.  See definition below from Wikipedia.  

DIBELS (Dynamic Indicators of Basic Early Literacy Skills) is a series of short tests that assess early childhood (K-6) literacy.
It is a set of procedures and measures for assessing the acquisition of a set of K-6 literacy skills, such as phonemic awareness, alphabetic principle, accuracy and fluency, vocabulary, and comprehension. The theory behind DIBELS is that giving primary school students a number of quick tests, educators will have the data to identify students who need additional assistance and to monitor the effectiveness of intervention strategies.
This formative early literacy assessment was created by Dr. Roland Good and Dr. Ruth Kaminski of the Dynamic Measurement Group. Research about this type of testing was first done at theUniversity of Oregon. DIBELS is used by some kindergarten through sixth grade teachers in the United States to screen for whether students are at risk of reading difficulty, and to monitor student progress and guide instruction.
The DIBELS comprise a developmental sequence of one-minute measures: recognizing initial sounds (phonemic awareness), naming the letters of the alphabet (alphabetic principle), segmenting words into phonemes (phonemic awareness), reading nonsense words (alphabetic principle), oral reading of a passage (accuracy and fluency), retelling (comprehension), and word use (vocabulary).

Wolf ends this chapter by noting that for people to become lifelong readers there must be an emotional engagement and students need encouragement to take on harder and harder material.  

And I will end with a quote from the book (which are may favorite part of this book)

At any age, the reader must come across" the child reader is the most eager and quick to do so;he not only lends to the story, he flings into the story the whole of his sensuous experience which from being limited is the more intense.        -Elizabeth Bowen (Irish novelist and short story writer)


7 comments:

  1. I watched this TED talk a while back! She is incredible! All kids need someone to champion for them. I pride myself in being a champion for my kids. Once they know that you are on their side, they will do anything and everything for you. Their learning increases and so does their self-worth!

    I appreciate what you referred to about readers needing the emotional encouragement to take on hard material. In education, we have surrounded this exact ideal with words like scaffolding and pedagogy. When reality and common sense tell us to just be real and do it with them. Through all of my years in school (prior to being an educator), my favorite teachers weren't the lecturers or the assignment givers. They were the teachers who work with me. They were the ones who made the difference. (And they probably weren't data-driven, follow-the-standards kind of teachers, either...)

    ReplyDelete
  2. I pride myself on being the one who works with them. Let's face it, education is important, but sometimes life gets in the way. My students are community college freshman most of whom are adults who realize that they need college to better themselves. Their lives are messy and I give them as much room as they need to succeed. Thanks for responding Heather!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Love the inspirational video. She tapped on one of the complaints I have had with teaching...all of the data driven instruction tends to suck the humanity out of the job. Yet, when we take a step back and get to know the children we teach, we teach them a hundred times better! I am saving the video. Thanks for sharing.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This is more of a personal comment, but I love that you were able to find a text that you can relate to directly. Telling a personal story always brings a blog post home, and I think it is such a great way to show practical application. The truth is that we all learn differently, and I can only hope that I am able to embrace those differences when I start teaching.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I can appreciate how Wolfe along with you, close this section. It is a very empowering statement to an aspiring educator. Emotional engagements can be facilitated and directed in such positive ways. And the power of encouragement to push for harder more challenging material for our students is inspiring.

    ReplyDelete
  6. So a veteran, retired resource teacher just brought up DIBELS with me this week. I had never heard of this before. But as I read above, DIBELS can even include nonsense words. Would this then measure fluency? Or is fluency the understanding and comprehension of each word, not just the pronunciation? I am going to have to spend time researching this :)

    I am thinking back, and don't think any of my kids' teachers have mentioned fluency before to me. funny how we, as teachers, can still feel so unsure of what our own kids' teachers are talking about half the time. we do get stuck in our own classroom worlds too much of the time. as a mom and parent, i sometimes dont even get that my kids teachers are talking about at conferences, but am afraid to admit it. imagine how our struggling parents must feel. i have always had positive experiences with school--both my own and my kids-- so i cringe when i think of how parents who had negative school experiences must feel when they are sitting in a parent teacher conference and cant really comprehend what the teacher is telling them. i always try to put myself in the parents place, and really explain carefully. cause it sucks to not get it, and not want to ask!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. ....and to reiterate what I just meant, I didn't let on that I didn't know what she was talking about in regards to DIBELS. ugh. somedays you feel like a fraud!

      Delete